
1. Will we ever see prototype, unproduced, or canceled figures from the last 30 years? Or are they going to be hidden from us as long as Hasbro has the license? I'm still curious about what that Attack C-3PO was going to look like, even after all these years.
--Michael
I think it's possible, especially for anniversaries. We're getting rarer variants from 1978 in The Retro Collection, so things like vinyl cape Jawas and double-telescoping lightsabers will be affordable for the maasses. Maybe we'll see the same for other lines as we roll forward, and hopefully they're mindful of ages of fans as we hit 30th and 40th milestones for the era of nostalgia. (In short, don't make people wait until they're 80 for POTF2 stuff.)
Some have made the rounds, but many were in the hands of Kenner or Hasbro employees. I've been made privy to some smuggled specimens, many of which are not yet shown to the public. Given how much generation loss of employment has happened, people might want to show off more as time goes on. Prototype Archives has some neat stuff up, particularly in the POTF2 section.
I asked some Hasbro (formerly Kenner) people around (gag) the turn of the century and was told Attack C-3PO would have looked like C-3PX, and R2-D2 would have looked like R5-D4 with the rocket. I've also heard that it wasn't going to be that. Maybe there are multiple prototypes out there, I feel like someone in the 1990s implied the 1996 Attack R2-D2, Attack C-3PO, and Removable Helmet Darth Vader prototypes never actually were made. Without evidence, it's hard to say, but it is pretty amazing just how quiet some of this stuff has been in the age of the Internet while there are literal books on the topic for the 1970s and 1980s stuff.
I have been told by a few ex-toymaker employees that there are an upper echelon of well-heeled toy collectors that get rare prototype stuff and never, ever talk about it. Nobody takes and shares photos, and nobody brags about their findings. There are things locked away for this lifetime that we may never get to see, and future generations just plain won't care about when those collections get sold or scattered to the four winds.


2. Not too long ago I bought the original Starspeeder 3000 vehicle from Disney and was blown away when I opened the box and they included a carded and loose version of the original Captain Rex Droid from the Star Tours ride. Why doesn't Hasbro do this with their pack-in figures, it seems like a no brainer!
--EJ
Almost everything boils down to costs and money - or possibly repeat sales. That Starspeeder 3000 was quite expensive. How do you feel about paying an extra $13-$20 for a duplicate bagged pack-in figure?
Hasbro is pretty aware that some people will buy a ship just to get the figure - they don't necessarily want the vehicle. By including a spare figure, customers could sell the loose (or carded) figure to recoup costs. This might also cost Hasbro another sale of a $60-$200 vehicle or playset. For mass-release items, this could be an issue. For HasLab, it could stop an item from being fully funded - even if it is something I'd happily pay more for.
Presumably, Disney only making a limited run of their item doesn't need to care about such things, so it was probably more valuable to give the item more stuff in the box (at limited cost to themselves) and whatever happens, happens. (I didn't wind up getting one of those vehicles due to the high initial retail cost, which I kind of regret and kind of don't. If they make a cheaper one with seats more geared to Retro figures, though, I'm in.)
Hasbro did make one vehicle like this so far - although I assume it's to keep their costs down. The HasLab Republic Gunship, which I actually need to open still, has one carded and one non-carded Clone Pilot in it. As far as troopers go I think it's always a good idea to err on including an extra if you can't be bothered to sell it in the main line.
I don't know what the actual cost to Hasbro is to make an extra figure sans carded packaging, but I assume it would be pretty cheap. Cheap isn't free, so if it can be done for an extra $10-$12 MSRP? I'd love to see it. (I wish we could've had that option for the Cantina!) If they have to charge another $15-$20, I'd have to think about it. And there's always a tiny chance there could be a variation between the carded and bagged figures, which of course would drive fans to the brink of madness.

Special thanks to our generous Patreon patrons, especially: JT, Jared, Bobb, Christopher, Daniel, Dan, Tim, Jayson, Matthew, Michael, Robert, Stephen, Todd DrReiCow, Eddie, Jeremy, Mario, and Todd! Thanks for helping us keep the servers on!

FIN
I know it's trite to say "I'd buy a retro one," as I did in question #2, but there's a reason for it. It's not just "I like this format," but also "I like not paying $300 for a vehicle. Hasbro put out a pretty excellent Kenner-flavored The Vintage Collection X-Wing Fighter this year for $140. It has a carded Luke, an unpackaged R2-D2, and limited paint. It's nice - I wouldn't change much about its deco.
Last year, Hasbro put out an Epic World of Action X-Wing for $30. It is a little smaller, has a Luke, and doesn't have as many moving parts - but it was $30. If I were Hasbro and wanted to sell to collectors, I can see the wisdom of not doing kiddo vehicles. The Mission Fleet line didn't do well, despite the ships being of seemingly good quality. I bought a few just to check them out, but didn't go all-in because I couldn't put 3 3/4-inch figures in them. There aren't many Epic Hero ships, but they did a good job showing what a Retro figure could be - and they had pack-in figures - and were mostly $20-$30. That's remarkable, but sadly people didn't see the N-1 and go "Oh, I should totally get that for my kid." They wanted the fancier one, though, and Ross has the kiddo one for as little as $8. Which is, honestly, an absurd price for a very decent toy.
Had Hasbro put the Epic N-1 in Retro packaging, I can't help but think it would've sold better. But fans just kind of ignored it regardless, which probably lends credence to the idea that the black and silver packaging is what drives a lot of purchases and probably makes a good case that "openers" are an increasingly rare bunch.
While I very much dig the Kenner-style TVC X-Wing, I don't know if I have an appetite for too many more Hasbro ships in Kenner colors due to space and price. One per year? Sure. I'd love to see them find a way to manufacture a 3 3/4-inch scale Millennium Falcon toy at a price that you wouldn't feel bad about buying for a child. But it's hard to compete against similarly priced items, like game consoles or MacBooks Neo. For whatever reason the stars aren't aligning for people to want to pick up the more affordable toys, so I'm still hoping that Retro picks up enough momentum to warrant keeping around for remakes of vehicles and playsets for the next decade or so. And then it can stop and we can all retire while the younger people can buy 6-inch until that runs its course.
--Adam Pawlus
Got questions? Email me with Q&A in the subject line now! I'll answer your questions as soon as time (or facts) permit.
Social media? Sure. Bluesky | Fediverse | Mastodon | Tumblr | Instagram

| I'm on Instagram! All Pictures from a GameBoy Camera. |
![]() |
